Consultations
How it works Security Pricing Blog Log in
All articles Pricing

Smokeball vs Clio pricing per user and the break even rate for a five person firm

Clio prints only a $49 per user starting price and Smokeball prints none. See where intake and trust accounting sit and the per user rate a quote must beat.

By the Consultations team · November 2026 · 8 min read

The Intake Desk
Run intake for

Pick a profession, watch the brief fill itself

The AI runs the discovery consultation, qualifies the lead, collects details and documents, and books the paid appointment, then hands you a prepped brief.

Intake brief

Name
Need
Budget / fit
Timeline
Docs
Verdict

Pick a profession above to run the intake

Discovery consultation

live

Intake brief

Qualification

Scored against this firm's intake criteria, with the reasons on the brief.

Appointment

booked

at

Brief ready for

Brief ready

Live and interactive. Qualified, briefed, and booked.

Every lead qualified, briefed, and booked · intake and scheduling, not advice · you own your data

Run a sample intake · the AI qualifies, books, and hands you a prepped brief

Clio prints one price, plans from $49 per user a month, and Smokeball prints none, so neither can be fully budgeted from its website. The useful comparison is where features sit: Clio puts trust reconciliation on its entry plan and its intake product on a plan with no printed price, while Smokeball sells intake as an add-on on Boost and Grow and includes it only on Prosper+, its top plan.

Smokeball plan contents come from smokeball.com/pricing, read on 18 November 2026. Clio figures come from clio.com/pricing, read on 16 August 2026; Clio blocks automated readers, so we could not restamp it this month. We sell Consultations, an intake product that sits in front of either system, so we have an interest in the topic. The plan facts are the vendors' and the arithmetic is ours.

Smokeball vs Clio pricing side by side

ItemSmokeballClio
PlansBill, Boost, Grow, Prosper+Starter, Core, Signature, Elite
Printed pricesNone. Every plan shows a Get pricing buttonOne figure: plans start at $49 per user a month
What sets the priceUsers, plan, contract term and optional products, per the pricing FAQUsers and plan; upper plans quoted
Case managementFrom Boost. Bill is billing and accounting onlyFrom Starter
Trust accountingListed from Bill, marked fees apply on trust managementTrust and operating reconciliation listed on Starter
IntakeAdd-on on Boost and Grow, included on Prosper+ with lead management and inquiry intakeClio Grow included on Elite, add-on on Core and Signature, price not printed
AIArchie assistant is an add-on on every plan; Prosper+ lists intake powered by Smokeball AINot used in this comparison, see the vendor page
TrialNot offered on the pricing page; demo and quoteFree trial on Starter, Core and Signature; Elite is demo only

Most comparison sites put the same "$49 per user" figure in both columns. That number belongs to Clio's starting price. Smokeball removed its last printed figure, a From $149 per month line with 12 and 36 month terms, in August 2026, and the page we read today still shows no dollar amount. Any article that gives Smokeball a per user rate without a read date is repeating an old quote or a guess.

Which features force the upgrade on each system

On both systems the entry price is not the price most small firms pay. Three features decide the plan.

Case management

Smokeball's Bill plan is invoicing, time and expense tracking, online payments, trust accounting and accounting integrations. It has no client and matter management. A firm that wants a practice management system starts at Boost, which adds matters, a client portal, eSignature, eFiling and the Communicate messaging feature. Clio includes matter management from Starter.

Trust accounting

Both list it low. Clio lists trust and operating reconciliation on Starter. Smokeball lists trust accounting and reporting from Bill, but its feature table marks trust management with fees apply, along with online payments and eFiling. Ask Smokeball what those fees are before you compare totals, because they sit outside the subscription.

Intake

This is where the two diverge most. Clio's intake product is Clio Grow, included on Elite and sold as an add-on on Core and Signature, with no printed price for either. Smokeball lists Intake as an add-on on Boost and Grow and includes it on Prosper+, which also brings lead management, inquiry intake and advanced matter intake. Smokeball's FAQ describes Grow as designed for firms with three or more staff who collaborate on matters, so a small firm that wants intake inside Smokeball is looking at Grow plus the Intake add-on or the top plan. Our Clio Grow cost breakdown covers the Clio side in more detail.

What a five person firm can and cannot budget today

Take a firm with three attorneys, a paralegal and an intake coordinator. It holds client funds and wants web intake that screens and books. Here is everything that can be priced from the public pages today.

Setup, five usersPer monthPer year
Clio at the $49 floor (trust reconciliation, no Grow)$245$2,940
Clio with Grow (Elite, or Core or Signature plus add-on)Not printedQuote only
Smokeball Boost plus Intake add-onNot printedQuote only
Smokeball Prosper+ (intake included)Not printedQuote only

One row out of four has a number. That is the honest state of this comparison, and it is why the useful figure for a buyer is not a list price but a break even price: the per user rate at which a quote stops being worth signing.

The break even price to take into the Smokeball call

Suppose the firm's fallback is Clio at the $49 floor for practice management plus a flat priced intake product in front of it. Consultations Practice covers up to five professionals for $129 a month, $1,548 a year on monthly billing. The fallback costs $2,940 plus $1,548, or $4,488 a year for five people with intake.

  • Smokeball Prosper+ has to come in under $74.80 per user a month for five users ($4,488 divided by 60 user months) to beat that fallback, before the fees apply items.
  • Smokeball Boost plus Intake has to come in under the same $74.80 for the plan and the add-on together.
  • Clio with Grow has the same ceiling. If Clio quotes Grow at more than $25.80 per user a month on top of the $49 floor, the flat intake route is cheaper.

Run the same sum against PracticePanther if it is on your list: its Business Pro plan, with intake forms and trust accounting, is $114 per user a month on annual billing, or $6,840 a year for five, as worked through in our PracticePanther vs Clio pricing comparison. A Smokeball quote under $114 per user for Prosper+ beats that.

Contract term matters as much as rate. Smokeball's FAQ names contract term as a price factor and the page offered 12 and 36 month terms when it last printed a figure. A lower rate on a 36 month term commits a five person firm for three years. Ask for the 12 month price next to it and compare both against your fallback.

Where each one wins

Smokeball is the better buy when

  • You live in Microsoft Word and Outlook and want document automation, practice area templates and calculators built in.
  • You practice family law and want the FamilyPro add-on, or want automatic time capture with AutoTime.
  • You are ready for the top plan anyway and want intake, lead management and workflows in one contract.

Clio is the better buy when

  • You want a free trial and a printed starting price before you speak to sales.
  • You hold client funds and want trust reconciliation on the cheapest plan.
  • You want the larger integration list and plan to add tools around the core system.

Both are serious products. The mistake is choosing on the headline and finding at signing that intake, the feature that brings in new matters, sits on the most expensive plan of either one. If neither fits, our Smokeball alternative and Clio alternative pages compare the other per user systems.

The intake question neither price answers

Both vendors treat intake as forms and a lead pipeline. A form stores what the visitor types. It does not ask a follow up question when the answer is "my landlord kept my deposit", it does not check whether the matter fits your practice, and it does not book a consultation at nine on a Saturday night. Those inquiries wait in a queue until someone calls back on Monday.

Before you pay for the top plan to get intake, count what is being lost. Pull last month's web inquiries and missed calls, mark the ones that came outside office hours and the ones that never became a consultation. Our law firm missed calls article shows how to run that count. If the list is long, the cheaper fix is often a front door that works by itself rather than a higher tier for five seats.

Under ABA Model Rule 1.18, a lawyer owes duties to a prospective client even when no engagement follows, so whatever runs intake has to collect party names for the conflict check before the person shares details of the matter. The text of Rule 1.18 is short and worth reading before you automate it.

Consultations runs that conversation on your website. It asks your screening questions, follows up when an answer is vague, collects party names for the conflict check and books qualified matters on your calendar with a short brief. It sits in front of Smokeball or Clio rather than replacing either. The price is flat for the firm, not per user: $49 a month for one attorney, $129 for up to five and $299 for up to twenty with voice intake. See Smokeball pricing and Clio pricing for each vendor's full plan record.

Questions to put to both vendors in writing

  • What is the per user price of the exact plan with every feature on our list, on a 12 month term?
  • What does intake cost: is it a plan upgrade or an add-on, and is the add-on per user or per firm?
  • What are the fees behind "fees apply" on trust management, online payments and eFiling?
  • Is there a cheaper seat for staff who only enter time or answer phones?
  • What happens to the price at renewal, and can the rate be locked?
  • How do we export matters, contacts, documents and trust ledgers if we leave?

If MyCase is the third name on your list, the same exercise is in MyCase vs Smokeball pricing, and the full Smokeball plan history is in how much Smokeball costs.

Frequently asked questions

Is Smokeball cheaper than Clio?

Nobody can say from public pages, because Smokeball prints no price and Clio prints only a $49 per user starting figure. For a five person firm that wants intake, Smokeball Prosper+ has to quote under about $75 per user a month to beat Clio at its floor plus flat priced intake. Get both quotes on a 12 month term.

How much does Smokeball cost per month?

Smokeball shows no monthly price. Read on 18 November 2026, Bill, Boost, Grow and Prosper+ each display a Get pricing button, and the FAQ says price depends on users, plan, contract term and optional products. A From $149 per month figure appeared until August 2026 and has since been removed.

How much does Clio cost per user?

Clio prints one figure: plans start at $49 per user a month. Starter, Core, Signature and Elite carry no individual prices, and Clio Grow intake is included on Elite or sold as an add-on on Core and Signature with no printed price. Read 16 August 2026.

Does Smokeball include client intake?

Only on its top plan. Intake is an add-on on Boost and Grow and is included on Prosper+, together with lead management, inquiry intake and advanced matter intake. Bill, the entry plan, has no case management and no intake. Neither plan holds a conversation with the prospect before the form is submitted.

Which is better for a small law firm, Clio or Smokeball?

Pick Clio if you want a free trial, a printed starting price and trust reconciliation on the entry plan. Pick Smokeball if Word based document automation, practice area templates and AutoTime matter more and you will negotiate a quote. Decide by the plan your must have features sit on, not the headline.

See how Consultations runs intake for your field on the use cases page.

Run this on your practice

Consultations runs the discovery consultation, qualifies the lead, collects the details and documents, books the paid appointment, and hands you a prepped brief.

Explore features

Run the intake and book the appointment.

Let the AI run the discovery conversation, qualify the lead, collect the details and documents, book the paid appointment, and hand you a prepped brief. Intake only, never advice.

See pricing

One AI conversation · qualifies and books · intake only, never advice