By practice area · Answering service for accountants
Answering service for accountants that screens new clients and books the consultation
An accounting firm phone does two jobs that pull against each other. Existing clients call to ask whether you received the 1099 and when the return will be filed. Prospective clients call, or fill in a contact form at 10pm, to ask whether you can take on their business, their rental properties or the three years of unfiled returns they have been avoiding. In March the first kind of call buries the second, and the prospect who waited two days for a callback has already booked with the firm that answered.
This page compares what the published answering services charge an accounting practice, shows the arithmetic for a three partner firm in season and out of it, and explains where an AI intake that qualifies and books fits next to, or instead of, a live receptionist.
One AI conversation · qualifies and books · you get a prepped brief
Pick a profession, watch the brief fill itself
The AI runs the discovery consultation, qualifies the lead, collects details and documents, and books the paid appointment, then hands you a prepped brief.
Intake brief
Pick a profession above to run the intake
Discovery consultation
liveIntake brief
Qualification
Scored against this firm's intake criteria, with the reasons on the brief.
Appointment
bookedat
Brief ready for
Brief readyLive and interactive. Qualified, briefed, and booked.
Every lead qualified, briefed, and booked · intake and scheduling, not advice · you own your data
In short
An answering service for accountants picks up the calls and web inquiries your firm cannot take, mostly between February and April and again before the October extension deadline. Live services such as Abby and Moneypenny bill by the minute, from $164 and $165 a month for 50 minutes on their published cards. Consultations is the flat priced option: it runs the new client conversation, checks the inquiry against the work you take, collects prior returns and books the consultation, from $49 a month for the whole firm.
Works with your calendar
Intake only · never advice
Why it works
What your practice gets with an answering service for accountants
Tax season without a per minute bill
Calls peak between February and April and again before the October extension deadline. A minute based plan rises with them. A flat firm price does not move when the inquiries do.
New clients sorted from status calls
Prospects are screened on entity type, services needed, years outstanding and deadline, then booked. Existing clients get a clear route that does not burn your intake slots.
No taxpayer data in the transcript
Intake asks what the work is, not for Social Security numbers or account numbers. Documents go through a secure upload after the engagement, not through a phone message.
What it handles
Run the intake, qualify the lead, book the appointment
Consultations runs the discovery conversation, asks the right questions, collects the details and documents you need, qualifies the lead, books the paid appointment, and hands you a prepped brief, all in one place.
- Answer new client inquiries by chat, email and voice when the office is buried in returns
- Screen prospects on entity type, services, years outstanding, state filings and deadline
- Turn away work you do not take (payroll only, crypto audits, out of state entities) politely and fast
- Book qualified prospects into the consultation slots each partner opens
- Collect the prior year return and IRS notices through a document request before the meeting
- Hand the partner a written brief so the first call is a scoping call, not a fact gathering call
Verdict
QualifiedDetails collected, lead qualified, and the paid appointment is on your calendar.
Why Consultations
Intake run, lead qualified, appointment booked
Not a calendar link, not a static form, not a separate qualification step. One AI conversation replaces the calendar link plus form plus qualification plus brief, and hands you a prepped client ready for the meeting.
Runs the consultation
The AI runs the discovery conversation, asks the right follow-ups, and collects the details and documents you need before the call.
Qualifies and books
It scores fit against your criteria, qualifies the lead, and books the paid appointment straight onto your calendar.
Intake, not advice
Intake, qualification, scheduling and admin only. Your licensed professionals give the advice. Client data is consented, private, owned and exportable.
What an answering service actually handles at an accounting firm
Most calls into a small CPA practice fall into four shapes. An existing client wants status on a return or an extension. An existing client got an IRS notice and is worried. A prospective client wants to know if you can take their individual, business or back tax work and what it costs. A vendor or a robocall wants your time. A message taking service writes all four onto the same list and the partner sorts them at 7pm.
The work that can be taken off a partner is the sorting and the capture. For a prospect that means the entity type (individual, sole proprietor, S corporation, partnership, trust), the services wanted (return preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, advisory, representation), the years involved, any notice already received, the state filings and the date that matters. With those six facts a partner can decide in thirty seconds whether to take the meeting.
What a receptionist, human or AI, must not do is give tax advice. Whether a cost is deductible, whether to file an amended return or how to answer a notice is a question for a credentialed preparer, and a good intake script turns every one of those questions into a booked consultation rather than an answer. If you want the general picture of what an AI front desk does, our page on the AI receptionist covers it, and the broader market rates sit on our answering service pricing page.
- In scope: entity type, services wanted, years outstanding, state filings
- In scope: whether an IRS or state notice has arrived and its response date
- In scope: booking the consultation and requesting last year return before it
- In scope: routing existing client status calls away from new client slots
- Out of scope: deductibility, filing positions, notice responses, any tax advice
Tax season is the reason per minute pricing hurts accountants
Most answering services meter by the minute or by the call. That works for a business with an even phone load. An accounting firm has the least even load of any profession: the IRS individual filing deadline falls in mid April and the extension filed on Form 4868 runs to mid October, so the year has two peaks and long quiet stretches. A plan sized for March is wasted in July, and a plan sized for July runs into overage every spring.
Abby, read on 18 November 2026, sells Starter at $164 for 50 Abby Minutes, Essential at $329 for 100, Professional at $599 for 200 and Growth at $1,380 for 500, month to month with no setup fee. AI answering uses half an Abby Minute per minute, so the same plan stretches twice as far on AI. Overage is billed at the plan rate per minute, which the page does not print as a separate figure, so the arithmetic below divides plan price by included minutes.
Moneypenny, read on 16 November 2026, prints live plans at $165 for 50 minutes, $265 for 100, $422 for 200 and $985 for 500, and AI plans at $99 for 50 calls up to $775 for 500 calls. Our Moneypenny alternative page breaks those plans down in full, and the case for each billing model is laid out in per minute vs per call answering service pricing.
- Ask whether existing client status calls count against the same minutes as new client calls
- Ask the billing increment and whether a 20 second call bills a full minute
- Ask whether you can change plan in February and change back in May without a fee
- Divide plan price by included minutes, that is the rate overage will be billed at on Abby
Worked example for a three partner CPA firm
Take a three partner firm with two staff accountants. In February, March and April it gets about 120 new client inquiries a month plus 200 status calls from existing clients. From May to January it gets about 30 new client inquiries and 60 status calls a month. Assume four minutes for a new client call and two minutes for a status call, which is generous to the answering services.
In season that is 480 plus 400, or 880 minutes a month. On Abby Growth, 500 included minutes at $1,380 leaves 380 minutes billed at the plan rate of $2.76, so about $2,429 a month. On Moneypenny live, the 500 minute plan at $985 is the largest printed tier, so the other 380 minutes run at its overage rate. Out of season the load is 120 plus 120, or 240 minutes, which fits Abby Professional plus 40 minutes at about $3.00, roughly $719, or Moneypenny live 200 at $422 plus 40 minutes of overage.
Across a year that is roughly 3 times $2,429 plus 9 times $719 on Abby live, about $13,756, before any change of plan fees. The same firm on Consultations Firm, which adds voice to chat and email intake, pays $299 a month or $1,788 a year on annual billing, and existing client status calls can be sent to your portal or voicemail instead of consuming a plan. That comparison is not perfectly like for like: a live service answers status calls with a person, and some firms want exactly that. The honest split is a person for existing clients during office hours and software for new client intake around the clock.
- Abby Growth in season, 880 minutes: about $2,429 a month (our arithmetic on the 18 November card)
- Abby Professional off season, 240 minutes: about $719 a month
- Consultations Firm with voice and chat intake: $299 a month, or $149 a month billed yearly
- Consultations Practice for up to five professionals, chat and email intake with document collection: $129 a month
Security rules that shape an accounting intake script
Paid preparers are financial institutions under the FTC Safeguards Rule and must keep a written information security plan. The IRS guide for tax professionals, Publication 4557, sets out what that plan covers. The practical rule for intake is simple: the first conversation does not need a Social Security number, a bank account or a login, so it should never ask for one. Ask what the work is and when it is due, and collect documents only after the engagement letter through a secure upload.
This is where a scripted intake beats a rushed person in March. A caller who starts reading out their SSN is stopped the same way every time, and the transcript holds the scope of work, not the identifiers a breach would expose.
Household employment is a good test of a script. Families who hire an in home caregiver directly, for example through a marketplace such as Aides, often become household employers and owe Schedule H and W-2 filings they did not expect, as the IRS explains in Publication 926. An intake that asks whether anyone was paid to work in the home catches that engagement at the first contact instead of in April.
Where Consultations fits in an accounting practice
Consultations is AI intake for professional practices. It answers the prospect on your website, by email and, on the Firm plan, by voice. It asks your screening questions, follows up when an answer is vague, declines work you do not take, books qualified prospects on the partner calendar and sends a brief. On Practice and Firm it requests documents such as last year return and any IRS notice before the meeting, so the first call is a scoping call.
It does not answer status questions about a return in progress, and it does not give tax advice. Firms that keep a live receptionist for existing clients usually put Consultations on the website and the after hours line and drop to a smaller minute plan. If you also sell advisory or bookkeeping retainers, the same setup is described for consultants on our client intake software for consultants page, and the onboarding step after the signed engagement is covered under client onboarding software.
Honest comparison
Answering service options for accounting firms and their published US prices
Every vendor figure below was read from that vendor own pricing page on the date in the note. Where a vendor publishes no rate this table says so rather than repeating a directory number.
| Option | Published cost | Billing unit | What a new client call produces |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voicemail | Free | None | A message, and a prospect who calls the next firm on the list |
| Abby (live or AI) | $164 for 50 to $1,380 for 500 Abby Minutes a month | Per minute, AI counts as half | A person or AI takes details, transfers or books |
| Moneypenny live | $165 for 50 to $985 for 500 minutes a month | Per minute | A person takes a message or transfers |
| Moneypenny AI | $99 for 50 to $775 for 500 calls a month | Per call | AI takes details and routes |
| Ruby (live) | $250 for 50 to $1,725 for 500 minutes a month | Per minute | A person takes a message or transfers |
| Smith.ai AI receptionist | $150 for 75 to $800 for 500 calls a month | Per call | AI answers and books |
| About $18 to $25 an hour through a staffing agency, office hours only | Per hour | A person during office hours, nobody at 10pm | |
| Consultations | $49, $129 or $299 a month flat for the firm | Per firm | Screened prospect, documents requested, consultation booked, written brief |
Abby read 18 November 2026. Moneypenny read 16 November 2026. Ruby and Smith.ai read 31 July 2026, the most recent reads we hold.
People also ask
What buyers ask about Answering service for accountants
How much does an answering service for accountants cost?
Published US plans start at $164 a month for 50 minutes at Abby and $165 for 50 minutes at Moneypenny live, and run past $1,000 a month at 500 minutes. A three partner firm in tax season can need 800 minutes or more. Flat priced AI intake such as Consultations costs $49 to $299 a month for the whole firm.
Do accountants need an answering service?
A firm needs one when inquiries go unanswered in season or after hours. If prospects wait more than a day for a callback in March, many book elsewhere. Count last spring missed calls and unanswered web forms. If the number is more than a handful a week, cover at least new client intake.
Can an answering service give tax advice?
No. A receptionist, human or AI, should not tell a caller whether something is deductible or how to answer an IRS notice. A good script captures the question and the deadline, then books a consultation with a credentialed preparer. That keeps advice with the professional and turns the question into a paid meeting.
Is an AI receptionist safe for a CPA firm?
It can be, if the script never asks for Social Security numbers, account numbers or logins, and documents arrive only after engagement through a secure upload. Paid preparers must keep a written security plan under the FTC Safeguards Rule, so confirm where transcripts are stored and who can read them before you switch it on.
Good questions
Questions about an answering service for accountants
Explore more
More ways teams automate client intake with Consultations
Client intake software
One AI conversation that qualifies, intakes, books, and briefs.
Learn moreConsultation booking software
Qualify and prep every lead before they ever hit your calendar.
Learn moreAppointment scheduling software
Scheduling that talks to the lead, qualifies, and preps the meeting.
Learn moreFrom the blog
Go deeper on an answering service for accountants
Per Minute vs Per Call Answering Service Pricing and the Increment Rule That Decides Which Costs Less
July 2026 · 7 min read
Answering servicesBest answering service for small business with 6 providers compared on published price
August 2026 · 9 min read
OperationsHow Much Does an AI Receptionist Cost? 2026 Pricing Guide
July 2026 · 9 min read
ComparisonsAnswering Service vs Voicemail and What Missed Calls Really Cost
July 2026 · 8 min read
Run the intake and book the appointment.
Run a sample intake, see the brief fill itself, then create your account for your own front door. Intake only, never advice, and your client data stays yours.
One AI conversation · qualifies and books · prepped brief in hand · intake only, never advice